top of page
Search

Whales Around Iceland: How Much Do They Eat, What Do They Eat, and How Many Are There?

Jul 28
8 min read

Updated: Oct 14

An evidence-based review of whale food consumption, fish predation and cetacean abundance in Icelandic and adjacent waters


Executive Summary: Understanding Cetacean Consumption in Icelandic Waters


Whales and dolphins consume vast amounts of prey in the productive waters surrounding Iceland. However, it is crucial to distinguish between three key metrics:


  1. Total food consumed is not the same as fish consumed.

  2. Fish consumed is not the same as commercially valuable fish removed from fisheries.

  3. A survey-area abundance estimate is not a headcount inside Iceland's territorial sea or Exclusive Economic Zone at any one time.


The most detailed peer-reviewed calculation estimated annual cetacean consumption in "Icelandic and adjacent waters" at 6.26 million tonnes. Of this total, 2.03 million tonnes (32%) was finfish, 1.31 million tonnes (21%) cephalopods, and 2.91 million tonnes (47%) crustaceans, primarily krill. This calculation utilized abundance data from the 1987, 1989, and 1995 North Atlantic Sightings Surveys, along with various assumptions regarding seasonal presence, body mass, diet, and energy requirements. The authors explicitly described it as an estimate of possible order of magnitude, not a precise current total.


In 2019, Iceland's Marine and Freshwater Research Institute (MFRI) published an updated calculation of 7.6 million tonnes of total food per year, including 3.3 million tonnes of fish. In this update, the three largest consumers were reported as fin whales (1.8 million tonnes), common minke whales (1.5 million tonnes), and humpback whales (1.1 million tonnes). MFRI also emphasized that uncertainty could not be adequately quantified with the available data, particularly regarding toothed-whale abundance, diet composition, and the duration migratory whales spend in Icelandic waters.

The latest complete, comparable multi-species abundance table remains the 2015 Icelandic-Faroese NASS ship survey. Its ten reported point estimates sum to about 773,000 cetaceans, but approximately 635,000 of that total consists of pilot whales and two dolphin species. Therefore, this sum should not be simply described as "nearly one million whales around Iceland." The survey covered a broad Central North Atlantic area around Iceland and the Faroe Islands, and several estimates have very wide confidence intervals.


NASS 2024 produced preliminary Icelandic estimates of 15,867 fin whales and 15,660 common minke whales, but the March 2026 NAMMCO status report labels both estimates uncorrected and not endorsed. Final estimates for non-target species are scheduled for review in October 2026. Until the review is complete, the preliminary 2024 figures should not replace the accepted 2015 multi-species table.


How Much Food Do Cetaceans Consume?


Two Estimates Answer Different Questions


Estimate

Total food

Finfish

Cephalopods

Crustaceans / krill

Status

Sigurjónsson & Víkingsson (1997), Method A

6.26 million t/year

2.03 million t (32%)

1.31 million t (21%)

2.91 million t (47%)

Peer-reviewed full species table; built on 1987-1995 abundance data

MFRI update (2019)

7.6 million t/year

3.3 million t (43%)

Not separately reported

Not separately reported

Newer institutional update; uncertainty not quantified


The 1997 estimate corresponds to an average of about 17,100 tonnes of total prey per day across the year. The 2019 update corresponds to about 20,800 tonnes per day, of which about 9,000 tonnes per day was estimated to be fish. These daily averages are merely a way to express the annual totals. Feeding is strongly seasonal and geographically concentrated.


The most defensible headline is therefore:


Cetaceans in Icelandic and adjacent waters have been estimated to consume roughly 6-8 million tonnes of food per year, of which approximately 2-3.3 million tonnes may be fish.

This range combines a peer-reviewed historical estimate and a later MFRI update. It should not be presented as a precise measurement for 2026.


Historic Consumption by Species


The table below reproduces Method A for the smaller study area, "Icelandic and adjacent waters," from Sigurjónsson and Víkingsson (1997). It is valuable because it is the only published full breakdown by consumer and prey class, but it is a historical model based on old abundance and diet inputs.


Species or group

Finfish (t/year)

Cephalopods (t/year)

Crustaceans / krill (t/year)

Total food (t/year)

Diet interpretation used in the model

Common minke whale

1,055,602

0

1,025,398

2,081,000

Mixed fish and krill

Fin whale

32,045

0

1,448,363

1,480,408

Predominantly krill

Long-finned pilot whale

154,943

619,771

0

774,714

Mainly cephalopods, with fish

Northern bottlenose whale

34,315

651,980

0

686,295

Predominantly cephalopods

Humpback whale

118,889

0

110,792

229,681

Mixed fish and krill

Blue whale

0

0

206,364

206,364

Krill

Atlantic white-sided dolphin

184,643

9,718

0

194,361

Predominantly fish

Unidentified dolphins*

138,728

7,301

0

146,029

Predominantly fish

Killer whale

139,342

0

0

139,342

Fish was assumed in this model

Sei whale

1,781

0

122,021

123,802

Predominantly planktonic crustaceans

Sperm whale

58,104

18,349

0

76,453

Fish and cephalopods

White-beaked dolphin

67,810

3,569

0

71,378

Predominantly fish

Harbour porpoise

45,823

2,412

0

48,235

Predominantly fish


The unidentified-dolphin row is a survey category, not a biological species


The model's diet assumptions were necessarily simple. For instance, an examination of 1,609 fin-whale stomachs from Icelandic catches in 1967-1989 found krill alone in 96% of stomachs. The model therefore assigned 97% of fin-whale food to krill and 3% to fish. The original minke-whale assumption was 59% fish and 41% krill, while humpback whales were assigned 60% fish and 40% krill.


Later research shows why these percentages cannot be treated as permanent constants. Minke-whale stomach samples collected in 2003-2007 contained less krill and capelin, but more gadoids and herring than earlier Icelandic samples. The broader Icelandic review by Víkingsson and colleagues also found significant shifts in distribution and feeding ecology associated with changes in temperature, salinity, and prey availability.


What Are the Principal Prey?


  • Krill and other planktonic crustaceans: The dominant prey in the historic fin-, blue-, and sei-whale calculations, and a major part of minke- and humpback-whale diets.

  • Capelin: An important forage fish for humpback and minke whales, and sometimes fin whales. Capelin distribution changes between Iceland, East Greenland, and Jan Mayen, so predation can shift geographically from year to year.

  • Herring: Important to Icelandic killer whales and increasingly significant in the documented minke-whale diet.

  • Sandeel: A locally important prey for minke and humpback whales, especially in coastal feeding areas.

  • Gadoids: Cod-family fishes such as haddock, cod, saithe, and blue whiting occur in the diets of several cetaceans, especially minke whales and dolphins.

  • Cephalopods: A major prey category for long-finned pilot whales and northern bottlenose whales.


How Many Cetaceans Are in the Wider Waters Around Iceland?


The following are the corrected point estimates and 95% confidence intervals from the 2015 Icelandic and Faroese NASS ship surveys. They describe the survey area, not the number continuously present inside Iceland's EEZ.


Species

2015 point estimate

95% confidence interval

Important interpretation

Long-finned pilot whale

344,148

162,795-727,527

Largest point estimate; exceptionally wide interval

White-beaked dolphin

159,000

49,957-506,054

Dolphin, not a large whale; wide interval

Atlantic white-sided dolphin

131,022

35,251-486,981

Dolphin; wide interval

Common minke whale

42,515

22,895-78,942

Iceland-Faroe survey estimate; other management-area estimates use different boundaries

Fin whale

36,773

25,811-52,392

Best-estimated abundant large baleen whale in this survey area

Sperm whale

23,166

7,699-69,709

Deep-diving species; wide interval

Northern bottlenose whale

19,975

5,562-71,737

Deep-diving species; wide interval

Humpback whale

9,867

4,854-20,058

Strong increase over the earlier NASS time series

Sei whale

3,767

1,156-12,270

Relatively few sightings

Blue whale

3,000

1,377-6,534

Concentrated especially west and north of Iceland

Sum of point estimates

773,233

Not a valid combined confidence interval

Includes whales and dolphins across a broad survey region


The lower and upper limits must be retained when the figures are published. Adding all lower bounds gives about 317,000, and adding all upper bounds gives more than 2 million, illustrating the very large uncertainty. However, those sums are not a statistically valid combined confidence interval because uncertainty is species-specific and not necessarily independent.


MFRI notes that the NASS program has documented substantial changes over time: fin whales increased markedly, especially between Iceland and Greenland; humpback whales multiplied; and minke-whale abundance fell on the Icelandic continental shelf after 2001, likely reflecting a northward distribution shift associated with reduced local prey availability.


What Do the Preliminary NASS 2024 Figures Show?


NAMMCO's March 2026 project update lists the following Icelandic target-species estimates:


Species

Preliminary 2024 estimate

95% confidence interval

Correction and review status

Fin whale

15,867

11,399-22,088

Not corrected; not endorsed


These figures are lower than the 2015 Iceland-Faroe point estimates, but a direct trend conclusion would be premature. The survey boundaries, realized coverage, and correction status differ. Poor weather, ice, incomplete transects, and the use of fishery-survey tracks complicated the 2024 analysis. NAMMCO states that the estimates must be corrected and reviewed before final use.


Does Whale Consumption Reduce Fisheries Yield?


High consumption does not automatically equate to an equivalent loss for fishing fleets. Whales consume krill, cephalopods, and non-commercial fish, as well as commercially harvested species. They may prey on fish that would otherwise be caught, but they also consume predators and competitors of commercial fish. Their nutrient recycling and movement affect ecosystem productivity. The net effect depends on the food web, prey age and size, location, season, alternative prey, and the response of other predators.


MFRI's 1997 multispecies simulation explored possible long-term interactions among fin, minke, and humpback whales and cod, capelin, and shrimp. The results were highly dependent on assumptions about diet and future whale abundance. MFRI's 2019 review concluded that existing knowledge was insufficient for a quantitative prediction of the effect of whale hunting on the yield of specific fish stocks.


This distinction matters for economic analysis:


Tonnes eaten by whales are an ecosystem flow, not a direct estimate of tonnes lost to commercial fisheries.

A defensible fisheries-impact estimate requires whales and prey to be mapped in the same place and time, with species-specific diet and energy models. Annual national totals alone cannot provide that answer.


Data Needed for a Current Icelandic Predation Model


A modern assessment should combine:


  1. Accepted NASS 2024 abundance estimates, with perception and availability corrections and full uncertainty distributions.

  2. Seasonal spatial distributions, including coastal bays and fjords that broad offshore transects may not represent well.

  3. Contemporary diet data, using stomach contents, DNA metabarcoding, stable isotopes, and fatty-acid analysis.

  4. Species-specific energetic requirements, including body size, reproductive state, and seasonal feeding intensity.

  5. Acoustic fish and zooplankton surveys, especially for capelin, herring, sandeel, mackerel, blue whiting, and krill.

  6. A spatially explicit ecosystem model, estimating overlap by species, grid cell, and season.

  7. Transparent uncertainty scenarios, rather than one headline point estimate.


This is a natural use case for integrating MFRI/NAMMCO survey data with spatial fisheries and environmental models: abundance indicates how many consumers may be present, while co-location, diet, and energy demand determine what they may remove from a particular prey stock.


Conclusion


The evidence supports four robust conclusions:


  • Cetacean food consumption around Iceland is measured in millions of tonnes per year.

  • Only part of that food is fish: the published estimates are approximately 2.0-3.3 million tonnes of fish, not 6-8 million tonnes.

  • The latest complete multi-species abundance picture is still based on NASS 2015, while the 2024 Icelandic fin- and minke-whale estimates remain preliminary.

  • Current evidence does not justify converting total whale consumption directly into lost commercial catch.


The scientific priority is therefore not another single national headline number. It is a transparent, spatial, and seasonal model linking whales, prey, and fisheries with explicit uncertainty.


References


  1. Sigurjónsson, J. & Víkingsson, G. A. (1997). "Seasonal Abundance of and Estimated Food Consumption by Cetaceans in Icelandic and Adjacent Waters." Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science, 22, 271-287. Article and abstract | Full paper (PDF) | DOI

  2. Marine and Freshwater Research Institute (2019). "Um afrán hvala við Ísland og áhrif þeirra á afrakstur annarra nytjastofna." MFRI statement

  3. Pike, D. G., Gunnlaugsson, T., Mikkelsen, B., Halldórsson, S. D. & Víkingsson, G. A. (2019). "Estimates of the Abundance of Cetaceans in the Central North Atlantic based on the NASS Icelandic and Faroese Shipboard Surveys Conducted in 2015." NAMMCO Scientific Publications, 11. Article and supplementary tables | DOI

  4. NAMMCO (2026). "NASS 2024 Updates", document NAMMCO/33/14. Project status report (PDF)

  5. Víkingsson, G. A. et al. (2014). "Recent changes in the diet composition of common minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) in Icelandic waters - A consequence of climate change?" Marine Biology Research, 10(2), 138-152. DOI and abstract

  6. Víkingsson, G. A. et al. (2015). "Distribution, abundance, and feeding ecology of baleen whales in Icelandic waters: have recent environmental changes had an effect?" Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 3:6. Full article | DOI

  7. Marine and Freshwater Research Institute. "Víðtækar hvalatalningar." MFRI survey overview


Editorial note: This report was prepared on 28 July 2026 from the local NASS and MFRI source collection, the peer-reviewed literature, and current official NAMMCO/MFRI status information. Numbers are rounded only where clearly indicated. Scientific names can be added to the tables if required by the website's house style.

 
 
 

Comments


+354 8935055

  • facebook
  • twitter

©2020 by Blue Economy. 

bottom of page